Dicevano di lei I
 
Stroncature, innamoramenti e indifferenze prima del 1955
 

STATI UNITI

Per le recensioni a Louise Brooks danzatrice cfr. ballerinaV e ballerina VIII
 

THE STREET OF FORGOTTEN MEN

 
 

THE AMERICAN VENUS

 
1.

Anonimo, Gleanings of the screen, "New York Times", October 4, 1925

"In the cast ... Louise Brooks of the Ziegfeld Follies, and Fay Lanphier who won the title of Miss America at the recent  Atlantic City beauty pageant"

2. Anonimo, Fay Lanphier for Granada stage, screen, "San Francisco Daily News", January 7, 1926

"the cast includes ... Louise Brooks and others of note"

3.

Anonimo, Granada shows Fay Lanphier in leading role, "San Francisco Chronicle", January 11, 1926

"'Some of the others in the cast are Ford Sterling ... Ernest Torrence, Louise Brooks and Douglas Fairbanks, Jr."

4. Anonimo, Fay Lanphier makes big hit Garden Theatre, "San Mateo Times", January 19, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the beauteous dancer from the Ziegfeld Follies, and W.T Benda, the internationally known artist, are also prominent in the picture"

5. Anonimo, The American Venus at Liberty tomorrow, "San Jose Evening News", January 23, 1926

"Consider Louise Brooks. Here is a Ziegfeld Follies girl who brings to the screen a rare type of beauty and a warm personality"

6.

Anonimo, Girl show will be big feature at the Liberty, "San Jose Mercury Herald", January 24, 1926

"Consider Louise Brooks. Here is a Ziegfeld Follies girl who brings to the screen a rare type of beauty and a warm personality"

7. Delight Evans, The American Venus glorifies youth and beauty at the Rivoli, "Morning Telegraph",
          January 25, 1926

"... and Fay Lanphier becomes 'Miss America'. This modern de Milo is a pleasant girl who is pretty but doesn't act that way. A recruit from the musical comedy stage, Louise Brooks, who plays a runner-up, is pert, pretty and promising"

8. Picture plays and players, "New York Sun", January 25, 1926

"Outside of one or two amusing scenes devised by the director - in which Ford Sterling, Louise Brooks, Edna May Oliver and Lawrence Gray assist ably - the main novelty of The American Venus is the sequence in color"

9. Harriette Underhill, On the screen, "New York Herald Tribune", January 25, 1926

"a charming comedy with some scenes in technicolor which delight the eye. Louise Brooks plays Miss Bayport, and she furnishes a great deal of perfectly legitimate comedy by inadvertantly being caught in the apartment of Hugo Niles and his wife, who arrives unexpectedly"

10. Quinn Martin, The new films, "The World", January 25, 1926

"It presents a raw and effortful desire to photograph scantily attired women without any sensible or appreciable tendency to tell a reasonably alive or plausible story. Any nervous high school boy might have done the plot and there isn't a director in captivity who could not have told the cameraman when and where and how to shoot ...  I do believe that Louise Brooks, who appears as Miss Bayport, is better looking than any of the other brunettes now acting in films"

11. Dorothy Herzog, The American Venus, "Daily Mirror", January 27, 1926

"A newcomer in Louise Brooks makes her screen debut. Louise plays a hard-hearted gold-digger type realistically"

12. Rose Pelswick, New pictures on Broadway, "New York Evening Journal", January 27, 1926

"It's good entertainment, and the bevy of bathing beauties includes Louise Brooks, who has a distinct screen personality"

13.

Anonimo, The American Venus, "Wichita Beacon", January 31, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a diminutive brunette charmer from the Ziegfeld Follies"

14. Anonimo, At the theaters, "Topeka Daily State Journal", February 6, 1926

"One of the most widely known and eagerly awaited screen productions. ... Others in the cast include Douglas Fairbanks, Jr., Louise Brooks, Edna May Oliver and many more favorites"

15. Harold Heffernan, The new movies in review, "Detroit News", February 7, 1926

"... and Louise Brooks, the latter a black-haired boyish-bobbed entry who cuts quite a figure in the parade"

16. Anonimo, Fay Lanphier is in picture, "Santa Barbara Morning Press", February 7, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a diminutive brunette charmer"

17. Jimmy Starr, Venus, a light comedy opera of beauty pageants, "Los Angeles Record", February 8, 1926

"With the aid of novel and trick camera stunts, the age old fashion parade is changed into something that even the male eye will linger on. ... Othwers in the cast who did exceptionally fine work include Edna May Oliver, Kenbneth MacKenna, Louise Brooks, William B. Mack and Fay Lanphier"

18. Charles J. Richardson, American Venus different, "Detroit Times", February 8, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the former Follies chorine, makes her film debut in the production and does well in a small role. This Miss Brooks just now is the patron saint of all chorus girls seeking admittance into the sacred ranks of screen players"

19. Guy Price, Theaters, "Los Angeles Evening Herald", February 8, 1926

"The most notable scenes are the fashion show and tableaux, which are filmed in color. Included in the cast are William B. Mack, Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. Ernest Torrence ... and Louise Brooks"

20. Anonimo, Film fare for the week, "Kansas City Times", February 8, 1926

"Then, as though that were not beauty enough for one picture, the director offers also Miss Louise Brooks, and many 'shots' taken at Atlantic City"

21. Carl Sandburg, Motion pictures, "Chicago Daily News", February 9, 1926. Ristampato in Id., The movies
          are
, Lake Claremont Press, 2000

"The tricks of the magician, who produces an amazing array of gowns worn by picked mannequins, employs the motion picture technique at what it can do most skillfully. Esther Ralston and Fay Lanphier are the feminine talent, also Edna Oliver and Louise Brooks"

22. Anonimo, Fay Lanphier in The American Venus, "Modesto News-Herald", February 11, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the beauteous dancer from the Ziegfeld Follies, and W. T. Benda, the internationally known artist, are also prominent in the picture"

23. Anonimo, Cast of American Venus, prize beauties, "Modesto News-Herald", February 12, 1926

"The women's side of this spectacular story by Townsend Martin is acted by Esther Ralston, the fetching blonde screen star; Louise Brooks, a diminutive brunette charmer from Ziegfeld's Follies; and Fay Lanphier, who was designated the most beautiful girl in America at the Atlantic City bathing beauty contest and was awarded the title of 'Miss America'"

24. Anonimo, American Venus has display of feminine beauty, "Lansing Capital News", February 13, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a diminutive charmer from Ziegfeld's Follies"

25. Anonimo, Girls and gowns dominate strand, "Pasadena Star-News", February 15, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a diminutive brunette charmer from Ziegfeld's Follies" 

26.
Anonimo, American Venus, "Photoplay", March, 1926

"Watch Louise Brooks, a new face. That gal's there"

27. Anonimo, New pictures at other theaters, "Post-Standard", March 1, 1926

"The cast includes Louise Brooks"

28. Anonimo, Esther Ralston in The American Venus, now showing at the Liberty, "Fresno Bee", March 5,
          1926

"Louise Brooks, a diminutive brunette charmer from Ziegfeld Follies"

29.
Frederick James Smith, The celluloid critic, "Motion Picture Classic", April 1926

"The much-exploited Broadway chorus beauty, Louise Brooks, is in the piece. She has a provocative face, but she hasn't learned yet how to make her knees behave"

30.

L. M. W., Stage and screen, "Ann Arbor Times News", April 5, 1926

"Louise Brooks has the feminine lead and gives a creditable performance"

31. Anonimo, American Venus to be at Capitol, "Birmingham News", June 13, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the beauteous dancer from the Ziegfeld Follies, and W. T. Benda, the internationally known artist, are also prominent in the picture"

 

A SOCIAL CELEBRITY

 
1. Pettersen Marzoni, Picture reviews, "Birmingham Age", March 29, 1926

"A newcomer also provides color to A Social Celebrity. She is Louise Brooks, who flashed a moment of inspiration in The American Venus"

2. Mae Tinee, Adolphe Menjou proves he's no one role actor, "Chicago Tribune", March 31, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who plays the small town sweetheart who want to make a peacock out of her razorbill, is a delightful young person with a lovely, direct gaze, an engaging seriousness, and a sudden, flashing smile that is disarming and winsome. A slim and lissome child, with personality and talent"

3. Josephine Hughston, Adolphe Menjou at Liberty in A social celebrity, "San Jose Mercury Herald", April 2, 1926

"Louise Brooks is Kitty, the girl who sets the pace in leaving the small town to dance in a New York night club"

4. Polly Parsons, Realm of silent drama, "Milwaukee Sentinel", April 13, 1926

"Menjou is excellent in his role with Louise Brooks, a Broadway dancing star, appearing as Kitty, and Elsie Lawson, another Manhattan dancer, as April"

5. Anonimo, Howard photoplay is A Social Celebrity, "Atlanta Constitution", April 18, 1926

 "In the supporting cast are Louise Brooks and Chester Conklin, both of whom are featured"

6. Anonimo, A Social Celebrity, "Morning Telegraph", April 19, 1926 (+ April 25)

 "Besides Menjou's capital performance, various rosettes and medals should go to Josephine Drake, Louise Brooks, Chester Conklin and Elsie Lawson ... Louise Brooks, provocative, alluring, would have been enhanced by better lighting or darker make-up, but that will doubtless come in another picture. She is, Heaven knows, potent enough as it is"

7. Anonimo, Adolphe Menjou in A Social Celebrity at the Rivoli, "New York Post", April 19, 1926

"There is, further, an attractive young lady named Louise Brooks, late of the Follies, dark, cute and accomplished at the Charleston"

8. Quinn Martin, The new films, "The World", April 19, 1926

 "It is no doubt the least exciting and the least imaginative of any of the recent Menjou plays, and even so it does sparkle. This is so because of St. Clair, Menjou, Miss Brooks and that heavy footed, sad-eyed daddy of a great many horrible comedies, Chester Conklin"

9. Picture plays and players, "New York Sun", April 19, 1926

"the beauteous Louise Brooks poses exquisitely and acts atrociously"

10. Harriette Underhill, On the screen, "New York Herald Tribune", April 19, 1926

"We like Louise Brooks, but not as a heroine. She should be always a lady who lures"

11. Katherine Zimmerman, Unreeling the films, "New York Telegram", April 19, 1926

"Louise Brooks, an attractive young woman who made her screen debut in The American Venus some months ago, puts in some good work as the Charleston stepper"

12.
Mordaunt Hall, The handsome barber, "New York Times", April 19, 1926 
 
"Incidentally, Miss Brooks, who impersonates the heroine, sometimes reminds one a little of Beatrice Lillie"
13. M. W., Mr. Menjou in another cinema joy on Valentine silver sheet, "Toledo Times", April 19, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who left Mr. Ziegfield's 'Follies' for a career on the shadow stage, has her first important role opposite him and does admirably. She is a captivating little brunette with the figure of a Venus"

14. D. H., A Social Celebrity, "Daily Mirror", April 20, 1926

"Miss Brooks is a vivid young miss, more at home in a jazzy role than a sweetly innocent one"

15. Rose McGowen, Social Celebrity shaved off nobility by chance remark, "Daily News", April 20, 1926

"Louise Brooks would have been ample excuse for making any picture. Here is a young actress who has fresh young beauty reinforced by one of the most expressive faces I have ever seen on the screen"

16. Rose Pelswick, New pictures on Broadway, "New York Evening Journal", April 20, 1926

 "It is about 85 per cent top grade entertainment and consequently much better than the average ... Louise Brooks is an unusually attractive girl who stirs the hero to ambition by leaving the same small town to do the inevitable Charleston in a Broadway night club"

17. Eileen Creelman, Social Celebrity opens at Rivoli, "New York American", April 20, 1926

" ... the saucy Louise Brooks"

18.
Fred., A social celebrity, "Variety", April 21, 1926
 
"And in Louise Brooks it looks as though Famous [Players Lasky] has a find that might rank in the Colleen Moore class providing they handle her right"
19. Anonimo, Pictures playing Atlanta this week, "Weekly Film Review", April 24, 1926

"The cast is uniformly excellent, but the players certain to leave an imprint are winsome Louise Brooks, who wears her clothes with a flaunt that no feminine member of the audience is apt to forget"

20. T. S., The current cinema, "New Yorker", April 24, 1926

"Miss Louise Brooks is a pretty newcomer but not an acting newcomer"

21. Anonimo, Adolphe Menjou in A social celebrity, "Film Daily", April 25, 1926

"Louise Brooks a cutey and with a quantity of good looks. She isn't exactly the heroine type though. She would make a far better baby vamp"

22. Anonimo, For film, "Philadelphia Inquirer", April 25, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a little dancer of Ziegfeld fame, is seen as the manicurist loved by the barber"

23. Mordaunt Hall, Cyrano's dulcet tones are missed in picture. The romantic barber, "New York Times",
          April 25, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the capricious heroine of the story, has the straightest and shortest eyebrows of any screen actress. When she arches them they curve the reverse way, and they give her a personality which clings to one's memory. She does a great deal of thinking during her scenes in this picture, and most of the time she appears really to be thinking of what is going on in the story"

24. Gordon Hillman, "Boston Daily Advertiser", April 25, 1926

"Miss Louise Brooks, a new leading lady, also does excellently"

25.
Idwal Jones, Granada comedy provokes laughs, "San Francisco Examiner", April 26, 1926
 
"... played by the appetizing and bob-haired Louise Brooks"
26.

Anonimo, Granada screen shows Menjou in clever role, "San Francisco Chronicle", April 26, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a newcomer - she played a rather outstanding bit in An American Venus - does nicely as Max's real sweetheart"

27. Curran D. Swint, Adolphe Menjou Granada star, "San Francisco News", April 26, 1926

"A very excellent supporting cast includes, besides Chester Conklin, Louise Brooks and Elisie Lawson in important roles"

28. Lawrence M. Montfort, Menjou funny in Granada's screen farce, "Illustrated Daily News",
          April 26, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who plays the small town girl who coaxes Menjou to emulate her example and try luck in New York is a comer and awfully good to look upon. Her straight-cut bob, black eyes and not too sweetly pretty face are different, and she displays some acting ability"

29. Anonimo, Social celebrity at Metropolitan, "Boston Herald", April 27, 1926

"Louise Brooks as the girl in the case is very attractive and dances the Charlestown almost as well as Bessie Love, althought more vigorously, yet she does little acting"

30. Anonimo, A social celebrity is Stanley picture, "Philadelphia Inquirer", April 27, 1926

"Louise Brooks gives a thoughtful interpretation to her part of the capricious Kitty"

31.
Anonimo, New films being shown on local screens this week, "Philadelphia Public Ledger", April 27,
          1926
 
"Opposite Menjou, Louise Brooks, a recent addtion to the screen from the chorus, possesses a vivacious personality and gives a fresh and promising portrayal"
32. D. W. B., Films of the week, "Boston Evening Transcript", April 28, 1926

"In this instance the manicure is no less provocative a morsel than Miss Louise Brooks, remembered for her bit in that specious puff-pastry, The American Venus. Miss Brooks has anything but a rewarding task in A social celebrity. Yet it would be ungracious not to comment on the fetching qualities of her screen presence. She affects a straight-line bang across the forhead with distressingly piquant cow-licks over either ear. Her eyes are quick, dark, lustrous. Her nose and mouth share a suspicion of gaminerie. Her gestures are deft and alert - perhaps still a shade self-conscious. In body she is more supple than facial play and her genuflectory exertions in the Charleston might well repay the careful study of amateurs in that delicate exercise"

33.
Anonimo, Adolphe Menjou now featured at Regent Theatre, "San Mateo Times", April 29, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a little girl who suddenly sprang into fame through her dancing in the stage production of Louie the 14th and who was awarded a role in The American Venus, has the second featured role. Miss Brooks is the little manicurist with whom Menjou is in love, but who later becomes a musical comedy star"

34. Anonimo, The low down on the picture, "Motion Pictures Today", May 1, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who achieved something of a reputation in The American Venus ..."

35. Roy Chartier, Film: A social celebrity, "Billboard", May 1, 1926

"Probably the most pathetic thing about A social celebrity is the casting opposite Menjou of Louise Brooks, a recent 'find'. She is absolutely negative so far as acting goes, lacks artistry and ingratiation, and so far as expression is concerned is a positive blank"

36.

Epes W. Sargent, A Social Celebrity - Paramount, "Moving Picture World", May 1, 1926

 
"Louise Brooks, who is coming along fast, does fine work as the manicure girl. A little too harsh in the more tender moments, she is very good in the more dashing episodes, and goes well beyond her previous accomplishments"
37. Frances V. Feldkamp, Movie reviews, "St. Louis Globe-Democrat", May 3, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who caused such a ripple of interest in her small role in The American Venus, is a flop as Kitty. One reason is that her makeup gives her a hard look that is neither becoming nor liked"

38. Anonimo, New pictures, "Time", May 3, 1926

"He has to help him in this venture an exceedingly personable and promising newcomer called Louise Brooks"

39. Betty Craig, Comedies and mystery greet Denver film house patrons, "Denver Post", May 10, 1926

"The supporting cast includes Louise Brooks and Chester Conklin in roles almost as fascinating as the role played by the dapper star"

40. L. M. W., Stage and screen, "Ann Arbor Times News", May 10, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who plays opposite Adolphe Menjou, gives her role vigor and strength of character"

41. Anonimo, Menjou, heart breaker, tries hand at barbering, "Portland Oregonian", May 11, 1926

"It introduces to the movie public a new heroine in the person of the sleek and boyish Louise Brooks. A little young, perhaps, but bouyant and of most engaging smile. There is no opportunity to learn whether or not she can act, but in her role of chorus girl she reveals the most beautiful pair of legs in the movies - which is a rather broad statement and a comment which would have been in very poor taste in crinoline days"

42. Harold Heffernan, The new movies in review, "Detroit News", May 11, 1926

"Louise Brooks, possessing one of the most striking and expressive faces ever to come to the screen, plays the heroine in a saucily successful manner"

43. Ella H. McCormick, Reel players, "Detroit Free Press", May 11, 1926

"Louise Brooks is the nifty stepper who forsook the orangewood stick and the bowl of soapy water and then made up her mind that life with the village barber meant more to her than luxurious clothes and the applause of hip flaskers in the big city"

44. Charles J. Richardson, Adolphe Menjou appears as barber in latest comedy vehicle, "Detroit Times",
          May 11, 1926

"The same for Louise Brooks. You find it hard to imagine this lovely bit of decoration as a domestic creature willing to retire from night life and a patron for the comforts of a four corner community"

45. Anonimo, Coming to the theaters. Columbia, "Washington Post", May 13, 1926

"Menjou is supported by a cast of unusual merit, including Chester Conklyn, Louise Brooks, Elsie Lawson and others"

46. Robert E. Sherwood, The silent drama, "Life", May 13, 1926

"Adolphe Menjou is, of course, excellent, and his leading lady, Louise Brooks, indulges in some eye-and eyebrow-play which is not at all difficult to watch. Miss Brooks looks to me like a safe bet"

47.

Anonimo, Social Celebrity subtle picture, "Los Angeles Evening Herald", May 15, 1926

 
 "The girl in the story is played by Louise Brooks, the lovely miss that made quite a name for herself in The American Venus"
48. Anonimo, New faces bow with Menjou film, "Washington Times", May 15, 1926

"Louise Brooks, also endowed with a prominent part in the Menjou picture, was a featured dancer in Ziegfeld's production of Louie, the 14th, and she joined the picture game to play the part of 'Miss Bayport'
in Paramount's production of The American Venus"

49.

Herbert Moulton, Local boy doesn't make good, "Los Angeles Times", May 15, 1926

"Louise Brooks proves a capable leading woman, considerably removed from the conventional type. She makes the character definite and gives it a quality of hardness that fits in nicely with her treatment of Menjou. She moves a bit too slowly, sometimes giving the effect of a carefully studied portrayal. This is particularly noticeable in several close-ups with Menjou, when she invariably turns her face toward the camera with great deliberation before speaking the subtitle"

50. Anonimo, Herb Wiedoeft and Orchestra are Kinema feature, "Fresno Bee", May 16, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who suddenly sprang into fame through her dancing in the stage production of Louie the 14th, and who was awarded a role in The American Venus, has the second feature role. Miss Brooks is the little manicurist with whom Menjou is in love, but who later becomes a musical comedy star"

51. Anonimo, Menjou stars in barber role, "Santa Barbara Morning Press", May 16, 1926

"Louise Brooks and Chester Conklin are seen to advantage in featured roles"

52. Anonimo, Adolphe Menjou in A Social Celebrity, current feature at the Kinema Theater, "Fresno Bee,
          May 17, 1926

"Louise Brooks, practically a newcomer to the sxcreen, and Chester Conklin, play the leading roles in support of Menjou"

53. Anonimo, Offerings at local theaters, "Washington Post", May 17, 1926

"In the cast with Menjou are Louise Brooks, Elsie Lawson, Chester Conklin and others. Their work, without exception, is good and gives excellent support to the splendid acting by the star"

54. M. K., A jowl-scraping baron, that's Menjou, "Washington Times", May 17, 1926

"... Kitty Laverne, expertly played by Louise Brooks"

55. I. S., Adolphe Menjou's latest one clicks, "Washington Herald", May 17, 1926

"Louise Brooks, of the Ziegfeld's Follies and Louie the Fourteenth, has the role opposite Menjou. She is credited with having made a leap from the chorus to stardom in this one picture. She is one of the 'finds' of
the season"

56. R. G. T., The new pictures, "Indianapolis Star", May 17, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who quits her position in the shop, dashing off to broader fields of endeavor in New York, where she becomes a cabaret dancer, has the feminine lead, contributing liberally to the value of the picture in spite of the meager possibilities of the role"

57. K. T. K., Asbestos, "New Orleans Times-Picayune", May 18, 1926

"Louise Brooks is rather cute as the girl"

58. Anonimo, U.C. Theater to show Menjou in comedy scream, "Berkeley Daily Gazzette", May 25, 1926

"Chester Conklin and Louise Brooks appear in the featured roles"

59. M. E. R., Amusing comedy opens Keith's summer policy, "Grand Rapids Press", May 30, 1926

"A familiar story, true, but Menjou's capable acting and that of Louise Brooks as Kitty make it pleasantly new"

60. Agnes Taaffe, Movies, "Minneapolis Daily Star", May 31, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a recent screen find and one who bids fair to rise rapidly in the ranks of popular stars, plays opposite Mr. Menjou and handles the role of the small town sweetheart who becomes a chorus girl with more than the usual ability shown by the beginner"

61. Hubert B. Mewhinney, TONIGHT - At Austin theaters, "Austin Statesman", June 5, 1926

"The girl is played by Louise Brooks, whom we remember as looking more attractive than either Esther Ralston or Fay Lanphier in The American Venus"

62. Alva Taylor, Love in Russia and Africa and New York, "Liberty", June 5, 1926

"Kitty [Louise Brooks] was the manicurist"

63.
A social celebrity, "Exhibitor's Trade Review", June 18, 1926
 
"There is one actress who is destined to succeed Gloria Swanson some day in the hearts of movie fans. And, to our way of thinking, that actress is Louise Brooks. This girl has charm, experience, looks, personality and BRAINS"
64. Anonimo, A social celebrity, with Adolphe Menjou, at Capitol, "Sacramento Bee", June 30, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the girl who created favorable comment as the Miss Bayport in The American Venus, has the role of the leading woman"

65. Laurence Reid, A social celebrity - Romantic comedy, "Motion Picture", July, 1926

"The provocative Louise Brooks enters into the scheme of things too. She has screen personality. Her expressions have an impish playfullness. She has a manner of teasing you to join her, while at the same time she warns you to keep your distance"

66.

Anonimo, A social celebrity, "Photoplay", July 1926

"Miss Brooks looks more than ever like stellar material"

67.

The screen in review: a barber-shop chord, "Picture-Play", August 1926

"Louise Brooks is the young lady with the black hair who saved The American Venus from a fate worse than death. This young lady, very recently from Kansas, is the newest of all those new faces that have been cropping up lately. And the prettiest, too"

 

IT'S THE OLD ARMY GAME

 
1. Anonimo, W.C. Fields, comedian Howard film star, "Atlanta Constitution", May 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a little lady who promises to create nothing short of a sensation because of her portrayal as the girl Fields would like to marry, gives a mighty fine performance"

2. Anonimo, Movies on view this week, "Indianapolis Star", May 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks is cast in the leading feminine role as the girl Fields would like to marry"

3. Anonimo, Pictures playing Atlanta this week, "Weekly Film Review", May 26, 1926

"There was considerable good acting on the part of the star, who was ably supported by Louise Brooks and William Gaxton"

4. Anonimo, Fields stars in new film, "Santa Barbara Morning Press", May 28, 1926

"Louise Brooks is featured"

5. Anonimo, W. C. Fields starred in Old Army game, "Modesto News-Herald", May 30, 1926

"Louise Brooks is featured

6. Anonimo, The old Army game featured at Olympia, "Miami Herald", November 27, 1927

"Louise Brooks is the leading lady in It's the old Army game"

7. Anonimo, Attractions at theaters tersely told, "Santa Barbara Daily News", May 31, 1926

"Of course Louise Brooks is in The old Army game just to add spice to the picture: she is certainly good to look at"

8.
Carl Helm, Army game is amusing picture, "San Francisco Examiner", May 31, 1926
 
"and the gloriously-wrought Louise Brooks ... Miss Brooks has nothing much to do but look lovely in a swimming suit, no difficult task for her"
9.

Anonimo, Hilarious comedy is featured at Strand, "Modesto News-Herald", June 1, 1926

"Then there is the piquant pert little Louise Brooks featured along with Mr. Fields. She contributes a performance second only to that given by the star"

10. Jimmy Starr, New comedy in Old Army game, "Los Angeles Record", June 5, 1926

"Louise Brooks is evidently very proud of her comely figure. This is the third picture in which she has worn that black bathing suit. However, Louise is a clever little actress"

11. Betty Craig, Many attractions are booked for the week, "Denver Post", June 6, 1926

"In the meantime the young fellow from the big town has fallen in love with the lovely creature that serves as the store's only clerk, who is none other than the captivating Louise Brooks"

12. Betty Craig, Great variety to be found in Denver's movie programs, "Denver Post", June 7, 1926

"W. C. Fields is very amusing, and Louise Brooks, featured with Mr. Fields, gives a dandy performance"

13. Josephine Hughston, Old Army game at California Is a laughing success, "San Jose Mercury Herald",
          June 10, 1926

"W. C. Fields is fully three-fourths of the show and Louise Brooks, who is rather new to screen stardom, comes near being the remaining fourth"

14. Anonimo, Fields hits fun high-water mark, "Stockton Daily Record", June 11, 1926

"Then there is piquant, pert little Louise Brooks, featured along with Mr. Fields. She contributes a performance second only to that given by the star"

15. W. R. S., Views and reviews, "Film Mercury", June 11, 1926

"A new actress has broken into pictures in the name of Louise Brooks, she shines like a gem in the rough"

16. Star-News Critic, Plenty of comedy on Raymond bill, "Pasadena Star-News", June 19, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a recent Paramount find, is not a bit hard to look at, and should be heard from"

17. Anonimo, The new movies in review, "Detroit News", June 20, 1926

"Mr. Fields' assistants in It's the Old Army Game are entirely unimportant. Louise Brooks' dark and beautiful features are purely pictorial and there is a half-hearted but unfinished attempt at a love affair""

18. Anonimo, W.C. Fields is starred in The ol' Army game, "Washington Post", June 20, 1926

"Louise Brooks is his [W.C. Fields] leading woman"

19. Anonimo, Offerings at the theaters. Palace, "Washington Post", June 21, 1926

"A whirlwind courtship runs through the story between Parker and Marilyn (Louise Brooks), but this has only a small part in the picture"

20. Anonimo, Palace - It's the old Army game, "Washington Star", June 21, 1926

"Louise Brooks is present, wears a bathing suit, and smiles sweetly throughout"

21. Irvin., Fine comedy film showing at Palace, "Washington Herald", June 21, 1926

"Louise Brooks played in Ziegfeld's Follies when Fields was running wild with Ray Dooley, et all. In this picture she has the feminine lead, and she surely confirms all promises of being the movie 'find' of the season"

22. Ella H. McCormick, Reel players, "Detroit Free Press", June 21, 1926

"Fields scored a splendid triumph in this picture. A great part of the success of the offering, however, is due to Louise Brooks, who takes the lead feminine part"

23. Ward W. Marsh, Fields whole show in Allen, "Cleveland Plain Dealer", June 21, 1926

"Louise Brooks and William Gaxton carry what is generaly known as the necessary love interest. Gaxton amounts to nothing, but Miss Brooks parades the personal magnetism to the limit, and late in the story is found wandering around in a bathing suit - for no sound reason except to display a form which assuredly needs not bathing suit to set it off. There is no complaint, however, on the appearance in the bathing suit"

24. Charles J. Richardson, W.C. Fields in true comedy, "Detroit Times", June 21, 1926

"Upon this frail framework Fields erects a pyramid of laughs with his droll humor and naive antics. it also furnishes the opportunity for Louise Brooks to offer a sparkling performance as the clerk"

25. Anonimo, It's the old Army game on screen at Missouri today, "St. Louis Globe-Democrat", June 27,
          1926

"Louise Brooks, the Ziegfeld girl with the million dollar legs"

26. Carl B. Adams, Photoplay reviews, "Cincinnati Enquirer", December 20, 1926

"Next to Fields, the chief attration of It's the old Army game is Louise Brooks, one of the most promising finds of the season. All that she has to do to make a hit is wear a bathing suit, which she does in this picture"

27. Frank Aston, Old Army game, "Cincinnati Post", June 28, 1927

"But before that, consider also that Louise Brooks, once in a one-piece bathing suit, is the most pleasing sight we have beheld since we saw our barber cut his own chin"

28. Frances V. Feldkamp, Movie reviews, "St. Louis Globe-Democrat", June 28, 1926

"Louise Brooks, fulfilling some of the promises she made in her first jump into the picture game, is a clerk in her store"

29. Nie., New films, "St. Louis Post-Dispatch", June 28, 1926

"Louise Brooks, exceedingly easy to look at, flits off and on the screen"

30. Polly Parsons, Realm of silent drama, "Milwaukee Sentinel", June 28, 1926

"Assisting Fields in his fun-making is a fine assortment of talent, including one Ford, and such theatrical celebrities as Louise Brooks, Blanche Ring and Rose Elliott"

31. Peggy Patton, Fields pleases in comedy film, "Wisconsin News", June 28, 1926

"Louise Brooks, Blanche Ring and Rose Elliot are the featured players. Each contributes a very good bit of acting"

32. T. O. Service, Service talks, "Exhibitor's Herald", July 3, 1926

"Louise Brooks is the other important person in the picture and, as insinuated rather bluntly on the occasion of her first appearance - in The American Venus - she's important. Miss Brooks isn't like anybody else. Nor has she a distinguishing characteristic which may be singled out for purposes of identification. She's just a very definite personality. She doesn't do much, perhaps becuase there isn't much to do but probably because she hits hardest when doing nothing, but nobody looks away when she's on screen. If Miss Glyn should say that Miss Brooks has 'it,' more people would know what Miss Glyn is raving about. But in that case she would not be raving"

33. Quinn Martin, The new film, "The World", July 5, 1926

"The drug store's counter attraction' is Louise Brooks, that attractive brunette. What Miss Brooks does in It's the Old Army Game to live up to all the ballywhooing which these columns have been carrying on in her behalf is practically nothing. That this Paramount party is handsome no one doubts. But so also, it has been said, is Carpentier"

34. H. E. Cherrington, It's old Army game, and who could be a more likable fakir than W. C. Fields,
          "Columbus Dispatch", July 5, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a dainty little brunette, with cute girlish ways, a way of flirting, a way of kissing and with a figure that formerly earned Ziegfeld or Carroll honors, looks like a good screen personality. If properly handled, she will be a real comer"

35. Eileen Creelman, Fields, new film star, is most of  Old Army Game, "New York American, July 5, 1926

"Louise is looking her prettiest as the drug store clerk. Her piquant little face has gained more expression since the dissapointment of A Social Celebrity. Yet she's in the picture more as decoration than plot"

36.
Mordaunt Hall, A clattering farce, "New York Times", July 5, 1926
 
"Mr. Field's clever and energetic performance is helped along by the attractive Louise Brooks"
37. Dorothy Herzog, It's the Old Army Game, "Daily Mirror", July 5, 1926

"Louise Brooks has little to do, but she manages to flash a slow, 
come-on smile for her sundry close-ups"

38. Roscoe McGowen, Fields-Brooks picture lacks real sunshine, "Daily News", July 5, 1926

"The picture is worth going to see just to look at Louise Brooks, one of the most ornamental young persons we have on the screen"

39. Cap La Roe, Grand, "Columbus Citizen", July 5, 1926

"... pretty little Louise Brooks"

40.

David H. Strauss, W. C. Fields's Old Army game holiday offering at Strand, "Morning Telegraph", July
          5, 1926 (+ July 11)

"William Gaxton makes a pleasing juvenile, while Louise Brooks is dainty and cute in a role that offers no great opportunities"

41. Harriette Underhill, On the screen, "New York Herald Tribune", July 5, 1926

"For good measure, however, someone has had the sense to write in a part for Louise Brooks. Now there is a lady we always are cheerful over when our men friends rave. We can understand it perfectly. Not only has this considerate some one written in a romance for Miss Brooks, but he has also provided her with a chance to wear a bathing suit!"

42. Anonimo, New photoplays, "New York Post", July 6, 1926

"Also involved, but only slightly, is the attractive Louise Brooks, herself late of the Follies"

43. Rose Pelswick, New pictures on Broadway, "New York Evening Journal", July 6, 1926

"Louise Brooks is ornamental in one or two bits"

44. Katherine Zimmerman, Unreeling the films, "New York Telegram", July 6, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who plays opposite fields, has little to do but look pretty, which she accomplishes by the generous use of both her screen expressions"

45. Anonimo, Picture plays and players, "New York Sun", July 7, 1926

"Louise Brooks, who is good looking on the stage, appears in this picture, and is good looking in it"

46.
Fred., It's the old Army game, "Variety", July 7, 1926
 
"a chance for Louise Brooks to strut her stuff. Miss Brooks photographs like a million dollars and shows a screen personality that's 'there'. This girl is going to land right at the top in the picture racket and is a real bet at this time ...  The picture in reality is Mr. Fields and Miss Brooks; the former for laughs and the latter for sex interest, and that's about all. Between the two the audience is going to be satisfied"
47. Hubert B. Mewhinney, TONIGHT - At Austin theaters, "Austin Statesman", July 7, 1926

"Brooks ... is the snappiest looking girl in the movies"

48. Anonimo, Fields' first comedy showing at Mosque, "Newark Star-Eagle", July 10, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a little lady who promises to create nothing sort of a sensation, because of her portrayal of the girl Fields would like to marry, gives a mighty fine performance"

49. Anonimo, Stage and screen, "Kalamazoo Gazette", July 12, 1926

"... and there is the radient presence of Miss Louise Brooks, who lends a piquant charm to the piece"

50. Anonimo, W. C. Fields and pole film at Mosque, "Newark Star-Eagle", July 12, 1926

"This picture not only affords a good deal of typical Fields comedy in a suitable story frame, but also reveals the possibilities of Louise Brooks, Follies girl who is making decidely good in the cinema. ... All told, Fields need not regret his first Paramount production. Louise Brooks, with a touch of piquancy, a good range of registration, and the conception of restriant, is pleasing as the heroine"

51. Anonimo, The low down on the picture, "Motion Pictures Today", July 17, 1926

"Louise Brooks shows great possibilities though her part is small"

52. O. C., The current cinema, "New Yorker", July 17, 1926

"Also mixed in the presentation is Louise Brooks, but, outside of what is nowadays called Personality, she contributes very little"

53. Roy Chartier, Film: It's the old Army game, "Billboard", July 17, 1926

"The story of It's the old Army game is as thin as the poorest chicken soup, and outside of Fields and Louise Brooks the cast means nothing at all"

54.

C. S. Sewell, Field's clowning and host of good gags makes his first starring film thoroughly amusing,
          "Moving Picture World", July 17, 1926

"Fields bears the brunt of almost the entire production in which Louise Brooks proves his efficient aid and adds attractiveness"

55. Anonimo, The old Army game, Galax play, features W.C. Fields, "Birmingham News", July 18, 1926

"Louise Brooks is featured"

56. Anonimo, W. C. Fields in It's the Old Army Game, "Film Daily", July 18, 1926

"Louise Brooks furnishes all the pictorial appeal. She is one of the prettiest of the screen's younger players"

57. Anonimo, Stage and screen, "Flint Journal", July 19, 1926

"Then there is picquant Louise Brooks late featured dancer of The Follies and Louis the 14th, who in this picture contributes a performance second only to that given by the star"

58. Anonimo, It's old Army game is a riot from start, "Lansing State Journal", July 19, 1926

"Louise Brooks, a little lady who promises to create nothing short of  a sensation, because of her portrayal as the girl Fields would like to marry, gives a mighty fine performance"

59. Anonimo, New pictures, "Time", July 19, 1926

"His lovely clerk (Louise Brooks) runs away with a real estate salesman"

60. Anonimo, The old Army game billed at Capitol, "Sacramento Bee", July 21, 1926

"Louise Brooks is cast as the girl Fields would like to marry. She is said to give a very pleasant performance"

61. Anonimo, Comedy features bill at Capitol, "Sacramento Union", July 22, 1926

"Louise Brooks promises to create a small sensation because of her portrayal as the girl Fields would like to marry"

62. L. M. W., Stage and screen, "Ann Arbor Times News", July 26, 1926

"Louise Brooks has the feminine lead and gives a creditable performance"

63. Anonimo, Plenty of comedy in Met film drama, "Baltimore American", July 27, 1926

"If Mr. Fields is responsible for the continuous fun, the beauty of  the picture must be credited largely to Louise Brooks, who takes the part of Mildred"

64. C. S. Sewell, It's the old Army game - Paramount, "Moving Picture World", July 27, 1926

"Fields bears the brunt of almost the entire production in which Louise Brooks proves his efficient aid and adds attractiveness"

65. Robert E. Sherwood, The silent drama, "Life", July 29, 1926

"Mr. Fields has to carry the entire production on his shoulders, with some slight assistance from the sparkling Louise Brooks"

66. Anonimo, W.C. Fields starred in It's the old Army game, "Waukesha Daily Freeman", August 5, 1926

"Louise Brooks is featured"

67. Anonimo, W.C. Fields, comedian, aids The old Army game, "Portland Oregonian", August 16, 1926

"Louise Brooks, the pert young woman who will be remembered for her work in The American Venus and A Social Celebrity, the latter with Adolphe Menjou, has the lead role opposite Fields. She poses a bit. An excuse was found to get her into a bathing suit too, which wasn't a bad move, on the whole ... By the way, Edward Sutherland, who directed the picture, has just married Louise Brooks"

68. J. M. L., Richmond Roof Orchestra substitute on lyric bill, "Richmond Times-Dispatch", August 17, 1926

"Louise Brooks has a prominent place in the cast and adds to the interest"

69.

Anonimo, It's the old Army game, "Motion Picture", October 1926

"The decorative Louise Brooks acts as the romantic ballast. But she adds nothing to the picture other than a pleasing figure and a pretty pout"

70. Anonimo, At the movies, "Stevens Point Daily Journal", March 17, 1927

"Then there is piquant pert little Louise Brooks, featured along with Mr. Fields. She contributes a performance second only to that given by the star"

THE SHOW OFF

1. Anonimo, A hit on the stage; as good on the screen, "Chicago Evening Post", July 30, 1926

"Louise Brooks and George Kelly also handle their parts most effectively"

2. Anonimo, Offerings at the theaters. Palace, "Washington Post", August 2, 1926

"Louise Brooks, Claire MacDonald and Gregory Kelly are well cast in the support"

3. Anonimo, Amusements, "Washington Star", August 2, 1926

"Louise Brooks is cast as something-or-other, but as usual is conspicuous for her figure, her dramatic ability being perhaps not so good"

4. J. C., Stardom at last for Ford Sterling, "Washington Herald", August 2, 1926

"Louise Brooks played the role of Clara, all made over to suit her"

5.

Anonimo, Two new films hold fans interest, "Los Angeles Evening Herald", August 7, 1926

"The cast includes Louise Brooks, who does a bit of excellent acting"

6.

Leonard Boyd, Ford Sterling wins laurels in Show off, "Los Angeles Examiner", August 7, 1926

"The balance of the cast, Louise Brooks, Grgeory Kelly, C. W. Goodrich and Joseph Smalley, had parts which kept them well in the background a large part of the time"

7. P. S. Harrison, The show off - with Ford Sterling, Lois Wilson, Louise Brooks and Gregory Kelly, "Harrison's Reports", August
          7, 1926

"Louise Brooks makes a good sweetheart of  the heroine's brother; in the scenes where she is shown upbraiding the hero for having brought misery upon the heroine's family, she is very good"

8.

Herbert Moulton, Sterling shines in Show-off, "Los Angeles Times", August 7, 1926

"The sweetheart of the brother is played by Louise Brooks, who does well in a negligible role"

9. Gordon Hillman, Show off is sparkling film of real life, "Boston Daily Advertiser", August 9, 1926

"Louise Brooks seems slightly insipid beside the brilliant characterizations of her more experienced fellows"

10. Anonimo, The show-off at Metropolitan, "Boston Globe", August 10, 1926

"Her little brother and his girl, played by Louise Brooks and Gregory Kelly, look like the modern youths. They don't act like them"

11. Anonimo, The show-off at Metropolitan, "Boston Herald", August 10, 1926

"Louise Brooks is the Clara. The movie people decided that the unhappily married sister of the play was not suited to Louise, so the movie Clara turns up as a next-door neighbor, Joe's girl friend. Miss Brooks has little to do but wear form-revealing gowns and ever so often uteer a 'wise crack,' for all titles of this nature are put right in her mouth"

12.
John McNulty, The show off - you may not like it but it is good, "Columbus Citizen", August 23, 1926
 
"Louise Brooks (the bold thing) is as luscious as can be"
13. Anonimo, The show off  less interesting as photoplay than on stage, "New York Post", August 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks as Clara has very little to do, but she made a charming picture"

14. John S. Cohen Jr., Picture plays and players, "New York Sun", August 23, 1926

"Directed by Malcolm St. Clair, the film boasts of exceptional naturalistic acting on the part of Ford Sterling, Lois Wilson, Claire McDowell, C. W. Goodrich, Gregory Kelly and - in one sequence - Louise Brooks ... Miss Brooks is best in the scene where she burlesques the pantomine employed by Mr. Sterling to describe his automobile experience"

15. Charles Divine, Unreeling the films, "New York Telegram", August 23, 1926

"But nothing is gained by the close-ups of Joe and his girl, Clara - parts played without conviction by Gregory Kelly and Louise Brooks"

16.
Mordaunt Hall, The braggart, "New York Times", August 23, 1926
 
"Louise Brooks, an emphatic type, with her dark hair and eyes and straight eyebrows, is bound to be noticed. Her istrionic efforts in this picture, however, are negligible"
17. Dorothy Herzog, The show off, "Daily Mirror", August 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks spitfires, prisses, oogles and calls it a day of heavy emoting. Miss Brooks is a distinct type, but she seems to suffer from ineffeciant direction and miscasting. She also appears a trifle rounded, for and aft, in this opera, but this may be due to her skin-tight dresses"

18. Rose Pelswick, New pictures on Broadway, "New York Evening Journal", August 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks is decorative as the girl next door"

19. David H. Strauss, George Kelly's The show off opens at the Rivoli Theatre, "Morning Telegraph",
          August 23, 1926

"The added character of the sweetheart next door is played by Louise Brooks, whose youth and beauty make up for her lack of warmth and spontaneity in characterization"

20. Irene Thirer, The show off on screen beats stage in some ways, "Daily News", August 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks, that pretty little thing drafted from the chorus to the movies, is absolutely lost. Just one close-up of her and Gregory Kelly lets you know she's in the movie at all"

21. Richard Watts Jr., Show off preserves in photoplay much of original charm, "New York Herald Tribune",
          August 23, 1926

"Louise Brooks, Gregory Kelly and C. W. Goodrich (here playing his original stage role) do well"

22.
Rush., The show off, "Variety", August 25, 1926
 
"Louise Brooks looks the part of the modern flapper type"
23. Anonimo, The show off, "Film Daily", August 29, 1926

"Louise Brooks is an added attraction but her part in the story isn't important"

24. Mordaunt Hall, Phlegmatic Mr. Keaton is a stylist as jester. The show off, "New York Times", August
          29, 1926

"Young Louise Brooks lends her interesting presence to scenes of this picture, but it looks as if her thoughts constantly wandered from the situation in which she and other players were supposed to be engrossed"

25. Anonimo, The new movies in review, "Detroit News", August 30, 1926

"Gregory Kelly and Louise Brooks also appear prominently"

26.

Don Krull, Out in front, "San Francisco Call and Post", August 30, 1926

"Louise Brooks portraying Clara, the girl who marries Joe, also do good work"

27. Curran D. Swint, The Show Off at California, "San Francisco News", August 30, 1926

"A romance has been developed between Joe Fisher, the inventor son, given a distinctive performance by Gregory Kelly, and girl next door, fetchingly portrayed by Louise Brooks"

28. Peggy Patton, Old soak ranks with year's best films, "Wisconsin News", September 4, 1926

"Louise Brooks, adds a dash of color to the offering with her daring personality"

29. Frank Aston, Comedy of home seen in Show off, "Cincinnati Post", September 6, 1926

"And henceforth and forever when we think of The show off we shall picture Louise Brooks and her display of hosiery"

30. Frances V. Feldkamp, Movie reviews, "St. Louise Globe-Democrat", September 6, 1926

"Adequate, but not outstanding support is given Sterling by Lois Wilson as Amy, Louise Brooks as Clara, Gregory Kelly as Joe, and Clara McDowell as the mother" - review in St. Louis, Missouri newspaper

31. Josephine Hughston, Ford Sterling is admirable in play at the National, "San Jose Mercury Herald", September 6, 1926

"Lois Wilson is the amiable and trusting little wife and Louise Brooks has the other principal feminine role as Brother Joe's sweetheart" 

32. Wood Soanes, The show off shown on American screen, "Oakland Tribune", September 6, 1926

"Ford Sterling in the title role lives the part, ably supported by Lois Wilson, Louise Brooks and a well-balanced cast"

33. Epes W. Sargent, Ford Sterling scores heavily in stage success that makes thoroughly enjoyable
          audience film
, "Moving Picture World", September 11, 1926

"Louise Brooks, Gregory Kelly and C.W. Goodrich form the remaining members of the essential cast"

34. H. H. O., Stage and screen, "Ann Arbor Times News", September 28, 1926

"Louise Brooks as Clara, her sister, almost runs away with the picture"

35. Anonimo, Stage and screen, "Flint Journal", October 4, 1926

"Louise Brooks and Gregory Kelly acquit themselves with distinction"

36. K. T. K., Asbestos, "New Orleans Times-Picayune", October 15, 1926

"Louise Brooks looks like a seat for the Follies"

37. Anonimo, The show off and frolic at Mosque, "Newark Star-Eagle", October 25, 1926

"Lois Wilson is seen as the girl who believes in him, and Louise Brooks as the girl who doesn't"

38. Anonimo, At the theaters, "Daily Californian", November 1, 1926

"Brooks shows her usual ability to portray character parts"

39. Anonimo, The show off to have final showing, "Berkeley Daily Gazzette", November 2, 1926

"Lois Wilson, Louise Brooks, and Gregory Kelly acquit themselves with distinction"

40.

Norbert Lusk, The screen in review: we all know him, "Picture-Play", December 1926

"while Lois Wilson tossed aside opportunities for shrewd characterization by wearing Paris frocks as a daughter of the Philadelphia poor. Louise Brooks, another little sister of poverty, likewise offended"


Index ] Pagina superiore ] [ Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica americana I (1926-1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica americana II (1926 - 1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica americana IV (1926 - 1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica argentina, sudafricana (1926-1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica inglese, belga, spagnola e portoghese (1926-1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica tedesca (1926-1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica italiana e francese (1926-1955) ] Louise Brooks, i giudizi della critica americana III (1926 - 1955) ]